nisee

National Information Service for Earthquake Engineering
University of California, Berkeley

 Need for Tying Together the Superstructure
 Earthquake 
Engineering
 Contents
 Ground Failure
 Ground Shaking
 Solutions
 Foundation
 Superstructure
 Construction
 Research

     As discussed previously, it is of utmost importance to ensure integral action (continuity) between the substructure and the superstructure (Slides J19-J21) as well as among the different components of each of the main parts of the whole structural system.  The importance of tying together all components of the superstructure is illustrated by Slides J51-J58.

J51.  Damage to a 2-story masonry building in El Centro in the 1979 Imperial Valley Earthquake.  The upper parts of the brick walls fell down on the sidewalk due to lack of proper connection with the roof.  A building should be tied at the roof and floor levels continuously from exterior to exterior walls.

J52.  Chimney collapse of a modern house, 1983 Coalinga Earthquake.  Most of the chimneys were thrown down because of the lack of proper connections (straps) to the buildings.  A chimney must be tied to the frame of the building at the roof and floor levels.  This can be achieved easily and economically through the use of adequate steel straps.

J53.  Collapse of a split-level wooden home, 1971 San Fernando Earthquake.  Large numbers of these split-level homes suffered significant damage because of a lack of adequate ties between the two levels.  The upper level ripped away and crushed the lower garage walls which did not have adequate lateral bracing.

J54.  Alaska Sale and Service Building, Anchorage, Alaska, 1964 Alaska Earthquake.  This single-story building, 200 ft square in plan, was constructed using precast reinforced concrete hammerhead-tee column sections, precast reinforced concrete walls, and precast prestressed concrete roof tees.  All of these precast structural members were in place and connected at the time of the earthquake, but the peripheral collar beam had not been cast completely.  About half of these structural elements fell down because of inadequate connections, emphasizing the importance of properly tying together all of the building components [7, 8].

J55.  Collapse of one of the stair towers of the Medical Treatment and Care Unit, Olive View Hospital, 1971 San Fernando Earthquake.  This unit had 4 stair towers, and 3 of them collapsed by overturning.  These stair towers were separated form the main tower unit, but the separation was inadequate, resulting in the main unit pounding against the towers, which overturned after the failure of the poorly reinforced supporting columns in the lower story.

 

J56.  Collapsed canopy of the primary school near El Asnam, 1980 El Asnam Earthquake.  Each canopy was about 3.5 x 19.5 meters in plan, supported by a row of four centrally located cylindrical columns.  The failure of this canopy was triggered by the large overturning moment developed at the base of the column [4]

      Note that the canopy in Slide J56 was flanked by a building on one side only.  Identical canopies that were placed between two adjacent buildings (one on each side) were severely damaged but remained standing (Slide 57).

J57.  Damaged canopy of the primary school near El Asnam, 1980 El Asnam Earthquake.  Note the significant damage at the top and bottom of the columns and permanent distortion of the columns.  The canopies hammered against the facade of the adjacent buildings, producing damage in the facades.  These buildings restrained the lateral deformation of the canopy roof thereby preventing its collapse [4].

      Analysis of the behavior of numerous bridges with multi-simple spans supported on piers during the 1964 Alaska, 1964 Niigata, and the 1971 San Fernando Earthquakes showed clearly that they collapsed for lack of adequate connections at the supports.  In view of this finding the State of California started a retrofitting program of similar existing bridges, tying the spans or segments of the superstructures by the use of restrainers.  Slide J58 illustrates the use of such a restrainer.

J58.  Retrofitting the hinge of an existing highway bridge by the use of restrainers, Oakland, California [19].

   

Importance of Integral Action of Foundation (Substructure) Click here for Table of Contents Selection of Proper System and Configuration for Superstructure

The University of California, Berkeley
Copyright 1997, The Regents of the University of California.
Structural Engineering Slide Library, W. G. Godden, Editor
Set J: Earthquake Engineering, V. V. Bertero

Site Design: Vivian Isaradharm,  Oct. 97.
Mail to:  eerclibrary@berkeley.edu